Webcom Radio is Now Playing: Pulp - Disco 2000

What Kind of Creature Is This Union?

 

A Response from Sara Salyers of Salvo/ Liberation to:-

Ewan Kennedy’s Comments on the Treaty of Union & Sovereignty.14/11.

 

Salvo has a motto, “Know your past; shape your future.’ More accurately, (but less succinctly), what it really says is, ‘Know your past to understand your present – because only then can you shape your future.” If Salvo has accomplished one thing since its launch in 2022, it has been to reframe the discussion about Scotland’s right to self-determination in terms of the constitutional, historic and legal questions that underpin it:

What is the union?

What, exactly, is the United Kingdom of Great Britain?

What and where is ‘the UK’ constitution?

Where is sovereignty located and what is it?

Why does it matter whether or not Scotland was a ‘voluntary partner’ in the union?

And if it matters, what does voluntary partnership mean legally and constitutionally?

This article cannot answer all those questions; there would not be space. But it can answer and contextualise some of the answers that underpin Liberation Scotland’s case. This is the case which the campaign group, Salvo is working to develop, publicise and advance as far and as fast as possible. First…

A Definition of Terms

Constitution: Every state has a constitution as a functional property of its existence in the same way every building has to have a foundation as a functional property of its construction. A constitution is the set of laws, principles and conventions that regulate the relationship between the government and the people and, also, the relations between the different parts of the government.

Where is sovereignty, final authority, located in a nation? How is it exercised? What are the limits and obligations of government? What are the responsibilities and rights of the people? How are these limits, obligations, responsibilities and rights regulated? The answers to these questions describe the fundamental principles of any constitution.

And these fundamental principles are especially well developed in nations whose constitutions have evolved over many centuries. Thus, in ancient nations, such as those of Scotland and England, the constitution becomes a fundamental expression of both the character of national government and the political values of the people.

Sovereignty: Sovereignty means ultimate authority or jurisdiction within a nation or state. In both Scotland and England, the Crown is sovereign but in both nations that sovereignty is modified by significant differences between the constitutional characters of the two Crowns. To be clear, where a monarchy and (or) a Crown exists, sovereignty is identified with the Crown

In Scotland, sovereignty is vested in the people. This principle is both solemnly affirmed in the Declarations of the Clergy and People, 1309/1310 and Arbroath, 1320, and is entrenched in Scots law: The Rebellion Act,1450, The Treason Act 1526, The Coronation Oath Act 1567 (still in force), The Act of Salvo 1663 and the Claim of Right Act 1689, (still in force as a condition of the Treaty and the union and formerly protected in Scots law under pain of treason).

Kingdom: A kingdom is the territorial jurisdiction of a crown, a ruler or sovereign. Any kingdom is a territory, as well as a people, held by, and depending on, the existence of a Crown.

Crown: A kingdom does not exist without a crown nor a crown without a kingdom. A crown is not merely a ceremonial headdress worn by a monarch. It is a constitutional institution whose character will vary from nation to nation. It is distinct from the individual who wears it. It encompasses territorial, judicial, political and economic authority, what we call ‘sovereignty’ as well as ‘ownership’ of the land and its resources. In ‘the UK’, it personifies the state itself which is often referred to as “The Crown”. Thus laws are enacted, justice is administered, and public administration is conducted in the name of the Crown.

Summary: Sovereignty means ultimate authority or jurisdiction. The Crown is the locus of sovereignty in a kingdom and the kingdom is the realm or territory of Crown jurisdiction or sovereignty. The Crown as an institution varies in character from nation to nation and continues with or without a monarch until it is abolished.

The constitutional character of the Crowns of England and Scotland, the role of monarchy and the locus of sovereignty in these two nations are key to understanding and, finally, defining the ‘union’ of 1707. They have a direct bearing on the so-called partnership which Scotland entered and, therefore, the constitutional issues which underpin the rights, and the scope of the rights, of the people of Scotland to the exercise of self-determination.

Background

In 1707, according to the Treaty and Acts of Union a new state was born from the two former kingdoms of England and Scotland, the Kingdom of Great Britain, later the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. This new state is the ‘Union’ from which I, and so many others, would see Scotland liberated. It is essential to recognise how specifically the Treaty and ratifying Acts define the character of the union because it is that definition, and that definition alone, which represents the agreed constitutional relationship between Scotland and England in the union. Anything outside this relationship falls outside the scope of the agreement. And when the agreement is between two sovereign nations, (arguably two independent states), each with distinct boundaries, history, culture and constitution, any departure from the agreed constitutional relationship undermines the legitimacy of a state founded entirely on that agreement.Article I of the Treaty of Union explicitly states that “the two Kingdoms of Scotland and England shall upon the 1st of May next ensuing the date hereof, and forever after, be united into one Kingdom by the Name of Great Britain.”

This unambiguously mandates the creation of a new political entity, the Kingdom of Great Britain, rather than the continuation of England with the incorporation of Scotland.

Article II specifies the unification of crowns: “That the Succession to the Monarchy of the United Kingdom of Great Britain… shall remain and continue to the most Excellent Princess Sophia and the Heirs of Her Body being Protestants.” Article II does not imply the dominance of the English crown but the formation of a single British monarchy, a new unified monarchy governing a new kingdom and, therefore, a new and constitutionally distinct crown.

Summary: What the Treaty and Acts of Union stipulate “shall” take place, (in order to establish a union characterised by that stipulation and agreed between the two sovereign nations), is what many eminent jurists including Lord Cooper of Culross, Scotland’s Lord Advocate, Dorothy Bain and our own Ewan Kennedy affirm as having taken place: “The Kingdoms of Scotland and England ceased to exist following the Union and were replaced by the Kingdom of Great Britain.”Implications for Scottish Liberation

This is the basis of the claim that “Scotland entered the union with England as a voluntary partner and not as a dependency” Not a small matter given that as a voluntary partner, Scotland is deemed to have exercised its right of self-determination in 1707 in order to create the state now known as the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

As the legitimate child of the parent nations of England and Scotland, that ‘new’ state has rights which sit above those of its parent nations. Under international law, it may not be torn apart by the unilateral actions of either partner, not if that ‘partner’ hopes for international recognition as a legal entity, a state. And that is what independence is – and all it is – international recognition of the state as a lawful entity. If, therefore, Scotland’s position is that of a voluntary partner in the creation of a new state from 1707, our only hope of liberating ourselves from this mankit union is, as Ewan, along with Robert McCorquodale, Mark Weller and others suggest, remedial secession.

This is an appeal to international justice, arguing Scotland’s distinct character, its past identity as a sovereign state, its present territorial boundaries and that the terms and conditions of our ‘partnership agreement’ have been so flagrantly breached, our national rights and wellbeing so viciously abused, that Scotland has a right to withdraw from the union. However, it’s important to understand that:

  1. The devolved Scottish government has no standing to bring a case therefore it would require a representative action by a third party, (member state), something that is far from common in cases of secession.
  2. As the case would be between states, (the UK and the state acting on Scotland’s behalf), the UK would need to consent to the ICJ’s jurisdiction over the case
  3. A ‘contentious’ ruling by the ICJ would take at least 3 – 5 years and much more if the UK delayed the hearings for as long as possible, as it could and certainly would.
  4. Alternatively, an advisory resolution by the United Nations would have no binding, legal force but only the effect of creating international support for Scotland’s case.

If Scotland is dependency, however, it has a right to pursue more than remedial secession. It has a right to decolonise without interference or agreement by the colonising English state:

  1. Although only a member state can initiate an action at the ICJ or represent Scotland at the General Assembly, there is one type of NGO which can obtain observer status, standing to approach UN Committees and more. This is a Liberation Movement committed not to the independence of a territory within a state but to a struggle for decolonisation of a nation and people, “subject to a foreign sovereignty” and to all the forms of oppression, either past or present, which colonisation entails.
  2. If Scotland meets the internationally accepted definition of a dependency, (colony) and this can be shown to and recognised by any member state of the UN, that state has an obligation in international law to transmit the status of Scotland as a dependency to the relevant organs of the United Nations
  3. Once recognised as a dependency, Scotland ceases to be regarded as a ‘voluntary partner’ in a union but, instead, is recognised as a nation and a people without a real voice, without any specific constitutional rights notwithstanding the supposed partnership and the partnership ‘agreement’, without a right to democratic expression and plundered by its supposed partner for the benefit of the mother country at the expense of the owners of the resources of the nation, the people.
  4. The obligation of all member states to ‘decolonise’ where they are found to administer any dependency is not an advisory matter nor a question only of international pressure. It is a binding obligation which frees Scotland from the prison created for it by the British state – the prison of its current international status where an independence vote without Westminster agreement would not result in true independence, recognition by the international community. Once recognised as a dependency, recognition of Scotland as an independent state would automatically follow a democratic vote in favour of liberation (ending our colonial occupation and administration by the state of England calling itself the UK).

So whether or not Scotland is in a ‘voluntary partnership’, whether or not the two kingdoms of England and Scotland were extinguished in 1707 or England annexed Scotland and threw the Treaty, ‘the voluntary partnership agreement, straight in the bin, matters more than the vast majority of Scots yet realise.

Which is our real position? It all depends on what really happened immediately after the signing and ratifying of the Treaty of Union.Spoiler Alert

For those readers who prefer not to spend time on the remarkable features of Scotland’s Crown and its profound differences from the Crown of England, here is a spoiler. What happened is that the Treaty was discarded except as a legal and symbolic cover, a grandiose fig leaf, for expanding English imperial control to Scotland.

A Bit More Background!

I have said elsewhere that the transfer of the sovereignty and constitutional character of the Scottish Crown to that of a new Crown of Great Britain was not possible. That is, it was not lawfully and constitutionally possible. And that is because the Crown of Scotland was not as most modern students of the union, including advocates of Scottish independence like Ewan Kennedy, seem to imagine it. This is not a question of differing opinion but of unambiguous evidence.

I am grateful to for the following illustration of the English Crown:

In an interesting article by Professor Martin Loughlin of London School of Economics entitled “Evolution and Gestalt of the State” he refers to an English theorist, J Southcote from 1559:

“The King has two Capacities, for he has two Bodies, the one whereof is a Body natural, consisting of natural Members as every other Man has, and in this he is subject to Passions and Death as other Men are; the other is a Body politic, and the Members thereof are his Subjects, and he and his Subjects together compose the Corporation … and he is incorporated with them, and they with him, and he is the Head, and they are the Members, and he has the sole Government of them; and this Body is not subject to the Passions as the other is, nor to Death, for as to this Body the King never dies”

Ewan adds, ”Although he was writing with reference to England, I’m not convinced that the concept was viewed any differently in Scotland.” I beg to suggest that what any of us may be convinced of is subject to the test of evidence.

Conventional feudal theory and practice was based (in England and elsewhere) on the premise that a kingdom was first and foremost a feudal entity and, in that sense, the property of its king or queen. In Scotland’s feudal system, this situation was radically tempered by the Crown’s status as representative of the Community of the Realm which vested that ‘ownership’ in the sovereignty of the people.

In other words, Scottish popular sovereignty derives from the Scottish Crown as representative of the whole Community of the Realm. It was, in turn, represented and worn by the monarch in a constitutional arrangement as different as possible to imagine from the English. The Crown of Scotland is the seat of sovereignty, final authority, in Scotland. The Crown of Scotland owned, (and still owns because it still exists), the kingdom of Scotland. And the distinction of the Scottish monarch from the Crown as an institution is explicit in the Scottish Coronation Oath which required the monarch to swear:

… the Rights and Rents, with all just privileges of the Crown of Scotland, I shall preserve and keep inviolate, neither shall I transfer nor alienate the same

(from the Scottish Oath of Accession 1689)

Thus were Scotland’s kings and queens, ‘the first among equals’ bound to preserve and defend the ‘Crown’, the Community of the Realm, and forbidden from transferring its rights, rents and privileges.

The popular sovereignty which comes from the Scottish Crown has become a ‘catch phrase’ used by independence minded politicians, (or those who wish to appear independence minded), whether they respect its implications, the contractual limitation of government, or not. But what are the implications? In what way does this contractual limitation make the people ultimately sovereign?

Popular sovereignty, as espoused by most political theorists (and most of our politicians), is based on the ‘social contract school’ which emerged in the 17th – 18th centuries with Thomas Hobbes (1588–1679), John Locke (1632–1704), and Jean- Jacques Rousseau (1712–1778). This version of popular sovereignty says that, since any government requires the consent of the governed, the people, for legitimacy, any government that has the consent of a people is an expression of popular sovereignty. By this reasoning any elected government is an expression of this sovereignty. (But then, so are popular dictatorships.) Push, even gently, on the politicians who claim to support the Claim of Right and Scottish popular sovereignty and you will find most have spun Scotland’s ‘golden thread’ into a very English garment, ‘social contract sovereignty’, the same garment that Scotland now wears: sovereignty at the ballot box, sovereignty for 24 hours every five years.

So what is or should be different about Scottish popular sovereignty? Most importantly it is not an idea, not a golden thread of Scottish thought. It is a fundamental, entrenched, constitutional principle deriving from the collective character of the Scottish Crown:

The Declaration of Arbroath, 1320, establishes the right of the people, or at least of the nobles, to remove a monarch (government) for breach of faith. That is authority (sovereignty) of the people over the monarch:

Yet if he should give up what he has begun, seeking to make us or our kingdom subject to the King of England or the English, we should exert ourselves at once to drive him out as our enemy and a subverter of his own right and ours, and make some other man who was well able to defend us our King.

But the first record we have of this Scottish principle is found not in the Declaration of Arbroath but in a document produced ten years earlier, the Declaration of the Clergy and People, 1309 – 1310. This Declaration asserts not only the right of the Scottish people, (the ‘common folk’), to appoint their own government but the authority, the sovereignty over their kings and governments by which to do it:

Therefore, the common folk and people of the aforesaid kingdom of Scotland, worn out as it is by the stings of many tribulations …. laid waste by a vast plundering, imbued by the anguish of constant sorrow, made desolate for the default of right governance, exposed to every danger and given to the occupier; and the people despoiled of their goods, tortured by war, made captive, bound and incarcerated, oppressed, overthrown and enslaved by the slaughter of immeasurable innocents and by continual burnings, and near to perpetual ruin unless speedy repair should be brought by divine counsel concerning such a disfigured and desolated kingdom and its governance; by the providence of the King most high under whose authority kings rule and princes govern, unable to bear any longer such numerous, great [and] heavy injuries, more bitter than death, often befalling their affairs and bodies for default of a captain and faithful leader, they agreed on the said Lord Robert, the present king, in whom the rights of his father and grandfather to the aforesaid kingdom still reside and thrive incorrupted in the judgement of the people, by authority of the Lord. And by the knowledge and consent of the same people he was received as king so he might restore the defects of the kingdom and correct things needing to be corrected, and might steer those that lacked guidance. And by their authority the aforesaid king of Scots was solemnly endowed agreed on the said Lord Robert, the present king….

By their authority and no other. This is the sovereignty of the common people over their monarchs and governments stated even more specifically and definitely than by the Declaration of Arbroath. The two declarations can be seen as ‘bookends’, however, the one asserting the authority of the people to appoint and the other the authority to remove their government and monarch. And it was neither a new idea nor merely a thread of Scottish thought. The principle underpinned Scottish government until the annexation of Scotland under the guise of a treaty. (On which more later.)

It underpins the Rebellion Act of 1450:

Item, it is ordained that if any man, as God forbid, commits or does treason against the king’s person or his majesty, or rises in fear of war against him, or lays hands on his person violently… or that assails castles or places where the king’s person shall happen to be, without the consent of the three estates, [he] shall be punished as a traitor.

So a provision for removing a monarch by force if necessary, in line with the ‘removal principle’ in the Declaration of Arbroath, was enacted almost 200 years before the English rebellion, (coyly reframed as a civil war), deposed and executed a king, (Charles I in 1649), without any statutory provision or constitutional tradition to support it.

It shapes the treason laws which identify the people as the Crown of Scotland:

Item, in the parliament held at Edinburgh on 12 November 1526, the which day, concerning the article of slaughters, murders and burnings, it is statute and ordained that the acts made thereupon of before and the old laws be kept, with this addition: that who comes and burns folks in their houses and all burnings of houses and corns and wilful fire-raising be treason and crimes of lese-majesty, because such deeds are exorbitant and more against the commonwealth than many other crimes

Treason and insult to the Crown of Scotland is, here, the commission of an ‘exorbitant’ (extreme) crime against the commonwealth of Scotland. The term, often rendered as “common weal” or “commoun weill” referred to the concept of the common good or the well-being of the community as a whole. This may be one of the clearest illustrations of the character of the Scottish Crown.

It was also made treason, (1703), to attack the Claim of Right Act, (which enacted the sovereignty of the people over government by deposing a monarch and his parliament), its principles, rights and protections. This followed William III’s attempts to remove the right to petition which the Claim of Right upholds (among others). Thus treason against the Crown might be committed by a monarch as much as anyone else.

The practice of Salvo by which any parliamentary legislation could be challenged if it violated anyone’s rights from 1592, made statutory in 1663, established the limitation of the Parliament (Three Estates) by the people in very practical terms.

At this point it is important to recognise two things: firstly the constitutional character of Scotland and the incompatibility of the institutions of the English and Scottish Crowns. Secondly the guaranteed protection of the Scottish constitution as a stipulated condition of the Treaty and the union. A 1706 Scottish Act is expressly required to be ratified along with any Articles of Union. Within this 1706 Act the Claim of Right Act is specifically named. And the Claim of Right Act upholds the Crown of Scotland, the requirement for any lawful king or queen of Scots to take the Scottish Coronation Oath (including the oath to the Crown) and enacting the sovereignty and rights of the people while affirming the legal limits of government.

So how, in terms of a constitutional mechanism, was the Crown and constitution of England merged with that of Scotland to create a new crown, a new kingdom and a new state? Answer: it wasn’t. Instead, Scotland was annexed, added to the English Crown and the English constitution under a new name, the Kingdom of Great Britain. Scotland has been administered under the English Crown ever since.

Did Charles III take the required oath to uphold the Claim of Right in its entirety? He did not. He took a cobbled together oath to uphold the Presbyterian faith as under the Claim of Right. Did he take the Scottish Coronation Oath mandated both by statute and by the Claim of Right? He did not. Did he take some joint coronation oath of the UK? He did not. What he took was the English Coronation oath of 1689, with Scotland added to its domains just as every ‘UK’ monarch has done since George I.

What Really Happened after the Treaty and Union?

In 1708, just one year after the Union, the English Parliament imposed English treason law upon Scotland, overriding Scotland’s distinct approach to treason, constitutionally rooted in the idea that the Crown represents the Commonweal, the Scottish people collectively. This was a critical shift and directly breached the condition of the union as well as the articles of the Treaty and Acts preserving Scots law. (The first attempt by Scottish MP’s to end the union took place in 1708.)

When George I ascended the throne in 1714, he added Scotland to his existing English title and failed to take the Scottish Oaths of Accession. This ‘tradition’ has continued ever since. (The first ‘Jacobite/Independence Rising was in 1715.)

The timing of these actions shows that the Treaty was disregarded at the earliest opportunity and can be seen within a broader, imperial context, where centralization under English rule was a priority and the Union was a means of extending English power. In other words, Scotland’s integration into the British state was not about creating a new partnership but about expanding English dominance. The Treaty provided a legal and symbolic cover for expanding English control and has continued to do so. (This may explain why every provision of the Treaty and the conditions under which it was signed and the union was to be accomplished, have all been discarded.)

I have attempted to show that the integration of the Crowns of England and Scotland was not possible for two reasons:

  1. Queen, Anne did not embody the Crown as an institution and she was prohibited by her Coronation Oath from transferring the sovereignty of the Scottish Crown
  2. Sovereignty was and is collective and comprehended all of the aspects normally associated with it, judicial, political and territorial authority; neither a parliament nor a monarch could transfer an constitutional prerogative they did not possess.

In the end, however, whether it was possible or not is only an added explanation for why Scotland was added to English control, why the English state continued while that of Scotland was extinguished. What matters is that England’s Crown has continued, constitutionally the same from 1066. The kingdom and state of England did not ‘suicide’ itself; it merely changed its name. Scotland’s Crown has also continued, though without its own monarch.

Scotland’s rights of sovereignty over its territory are vested in the Crown with its distinct constitutional and legal identity in Scotland under Scots law, compared to the Crown in the rest of the United Kingdom under English law. … This distinct identity was not affected by the Union of Crowns in 1603 and has continued since the Treaty of Union in 1707, when Scotland ceased to be an independent state but continued to be a sovereign territorial nation.

Scotland’s Crown ‘rights, rents and privileges’ are administered today under England’s Crown, the very definition of a dependency. (Though it acknowledges a different ‘Scottish’ character.) The primary, stipulated effects of the Treaty and Acts of Union, the creation of a single, unified kingdom under a single unified crown, remain unfulfilled.

And there is no agreement for the annexation of Scotland under an English Crown renamed the Crown of Great Britain. If there is no partnership agreement for Scotland’s status then there is, and never has been a voluntary partnership. And without a voluntary partnership, according to the Anglo-British state itself, Scotland is a dependency, a colony:

Scotland is a nation and voluntarily entered into union with England as a partner and not as a dependency. (Balfour Royal Commission on Scottish Affairs Report 1952-1954, Chapter One, presented to Parliament, July 1954.)

 

This can now be rephrased as follows: Scotland is a nation and a dependency, as it has no voluntary agreement for the union with England, as implemented.

Instead, it has the right to self-determination without interference by the colonising British state, the right to restoration of our distinct constitution, our sovereignty, our true history, our culture and our resources and the right to reparations for all that was stolen from us.

14 thoughts on “What Kind of Creature Is This Union?”

  • At yesterday’s meeting of Scottish Salvo hubs in Perth, Sara Salyers referred to the placing of the true facts of Scotland in relation to the Union, and in particular the very much noticeable lack of equality to the European Courts of Human Rights, next January.
    This presentation is in the form of some kind of legal documentation, placing Salvo’s case for recognition of the Scottish sovereignty being with the people, and in particular in relation to Scotland’s quest to end the Union in favour of its return to being an independent country.
    Have I got this correct?

    • Not the ECHR, Alan. The first steps towards correcting the perception of Scotland as a voluntary partner in a ‘merger’ and obtaining listing at the UN for decolonisation will take place in January next.

      • Can I ask, and I apologise for being overawed by all this. But in layman’s terms what does this mean in plain speak

  • Two points: No Monarch since the inception of the Union has worn the Scottish Crown, a requirement for becoming King or Queen of Scots. A Treaty between two Nations, can be ended by either Nation, with or without the consent of the other Nation, under the Vienna Convention.

  • Interesting. Will take a lot of reading some time.

    But meantime, while Indy supporters would want the remedy to be Independence, same would not be true for those who still support the Union, though polls consistently have that as less than 50%. So what I’m wondering almost off the top of my head, is this – is there a remedy that could be satisfactory to both “sides”, and therefore supportable by 100% of the People of Scotland?

    This could be to put the current situtation in the state it should have been if the Treaty of Union had been honoured, and also if Salvo had been possible with a reconvening of the parliament BEFORE the 1st of May to allow repeal of the Act of Union with England (ratification of the Treaty). In other words, to make in current constitutional terms, the Union indeed a voluntary one with the ever present recourse of taking steps to end that Union, enshrined in an agreed constitution.

    Not very well put, but I know what I’m trying to say – seek a remedy which is easy to agree, and doesn’t strengthen or weaken any arguments for or against continuation of the Union or separation / secession / dissolution. Easier for the UK Government to agree to – and for any external court or body to impose / strongly suggest.

      • It’s not so much that the UK Gov would want to agree to it, as it might be easier for the UN / ICJ / ECHR whichever would be applicable, to determine that that was the solution – i.e. remedy. Everybody happy (not really), and a delay brought in. Even if for a couple of years.

        The NSGT route would indeed by long and problematic, and perhaps puts us in a similar position to the Falklands. Which could allow the UK Gov to refuse to let us go until they were sure we could stand on our own two feet, have a viable economy, defence, international relations, etc. There was an old HoC or HoL committee report (2008?) about what woudl be needed to be done for the Falklands – they could in their incredibly nice and conscientious way, insist on doing the same for us. To which we’d at least think – no thanks.

        I’ve got a bookmark somewhere, would take time finding it.

  • Righty, old law is great, as long as it;s extant such as the 1689 Claim of Right. And referred to in multiple cases including the LA Reference one in the UKSC. Get out of that without moving. However, there is perhaps new law that serves the purpose of clearly delineating Scots Law, which could perhaps be used by the bold and adventurous. For instance this:

    The Scots “International Criminal Court (Scotland) Act 2001” doesn’t seem to be a direct equivalent of the EWNI ICC Law 2001, more perhaps from my quick scan about war crimes etc IN Scotland or for people becoming resident in Scotland.

    https://www.legislation.gov.uk/asp/2001/13/contents

    Which is interesting, perhaps in a Megrahi and MacAskill 2009 way, where he was released under Scots law on compassionate grounds, despite massive attempted pressure by the US – MacAskill’s finest hour some would say, backed up by Salmond of course.

    If Scots Law is different, THEN USE IT.

    • This would be within the context of ‘UK’ (the English/UK parliament is sovereign and makes the) law? All UK courts, including the SC, are constrained by the ‘UK’s’ constitutional framework which has, in practice, always upheld English dominance in interpreting constitutional matters. Within a legal framework where you have a ‘symbolic’ partnership, ‘symbolic’ equality’ and a ‘symbolic’ treaty, no interpretation of the law exists that would ever favour Scotland’s position over England’s/rUK’s. A possible exception might be a criminal case on the basis of a violation of protected national or civil rights at the Court of Session but it would have to be against a corporation or similar body as any challenge to Holyrood (the devolved Westminster administration) or Westminster itself would be referred to the SC as a constitutional matter.

      • It’s actually Scots Law not UK law. Similar in some ways to that Megrahi where he was released on compassionate grounds under Scots Law not UK law – I don’t think there’s a UK equivalent. I don’t think there’s been enough use of this – just one or two by the Court of Session.

        I just looked it up and for Megrahi wikipedia says this: “Alistair Darling pointed out that as a question of criminal justice, and thus a devolved matter, it would be inappropriate for Westminster to comment on it.“. Darling was a Secretary of State for Scotland for a time so in theory would know – though the Law actually had nothing to do with Devolution apart from it actually being administered by a devolved Justice Secretary (MacAskill). Also behind it of course was a popular belief Megrahi was fitted up; how much that had to do with the decision to release him, who knows.

        I think what would be needed is an action under that ICC (Scotland) Act – perhaps using its powers of arrest of assets. But IANAL.

  • My anxiety is not in Scotland’s Constitutional legitimacy, quite the reverse.

    However, it niggles me profoundly that the Scots Law “basket” we are putting all our eggs into was demonstrably inadequate to prevent Scotland’s subjugation, and at a time when the appreciation and distinction of Scots Law was surely at it’s height. With such legitimacy and rectitude on its side, why then, did Scotland “lose”?

    What failed Scotland in the 18th Century, and what threatens to fail us again in the 21st Century, is not the letter of the law, but securing common adherence to what that law already determines.

    Common adherence begins with Scotland itself recognising it’s own legitimacy and standing up to defend it. Even that has yet to happen. Common adherence for Westminster means Westminster reverting to an English parliament, because it is not, and never has been, the seat of sovereign UK government. Scotland’s sovereignty never once made it’s journey south.

    The third common adherence, is quite simply International Recognition; recognition of the new, (or more properly old) constitutional reality. Yet somehow, this seems darker than ever. Where does Scotland’s sovereign legitimacy lie between a new multipolar BRICS world which NATO has insanely provoked to the brink of WW3, and the stateless “Deep State” which has rendered the once proud USA a servile, vassal state, and instrument of war and destruction under Zionist command?

    Our “Pole” in that new Multipolarity seems destined to be bleak beyond all measure, and we Scots must find our courage to secure a different destiny. Don’t get me wrong, there are many of us who do have that courage, but I’m not sure we are braced and ready for Deep State interfence which doesn’t blink on the eve of the nuclear annihilation it seems determined to instigate.

    All of us, everyone, seem expendible. We, the people, are of no value to these lunatics, but our strategic position, resources, and military platform means everything. Will they cheat us? Of course they will. They already do. Look at the skewed garbage and disinformation on your TV screen.

    To the Westminster Government, itself a vassal state to Zionism, “losing” Scotland would be losing face in their lunatic war. Even as a committed Independentist, I’m not sure what will save us from this Deep State bogeyman which hides in the shadows and pulls our “democratic” strings. It literally destroys Nation after Nation who reject its dark umbrella. We must never underestimate it’s malevolence towards Scotland, our land, for which it has always harboured great jealousy.

    Please don’t think I’m being despondent. It may read like I am. But I am only anxious about this interference because the UK Union has never felt so imperilled and close to collapse.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.